Alec Nevin (Calogero), Jeff Brooks (Sonny), Trey Murphy (Young Calogero), Nick Fradiani (Lorenzo), Stefanie Londino (Rosina), Kayla Jenerson (Jane), George Vickers V (Tyrone), Benjamin Sears (Handsome Nick), Tyler Dema (Crazy Mario), Darius Vines (Jesse), Joey Trombino (Police Officer/Gang Leader/Carmine), Nathan Wright (JoJo the Whale), Martin Bonventre (Eddie Mush), Mark Sippel (Frankie Coffeecake)