John Gallagher Jr. (Johnny), Matt Caplan (Tunny), Michael Esper (Will), Tony Vincent (St. Jimmy), Libby Winters (u/s Heather), Rebecca Naomi Jones (Whatsername), Christina Sajous (The Extraordinary Girl) Ensemble: Declan Bennett, Andrew Call, Gerard Canonico, Miguel Cervantes, Joshua Henry, Omar Lopez-Cepero (for Brian Charles Johnson's track), Lorin Latarro (for Libby Winters's track), Chase Peacock, Theo Stockman, Ben Thompson, Alysha Umphress