Christy Altomare (Anya), Cody Simpson (Dmitry), Constantine Germanacos (Gleb Vaganov), John Bolton (Vlad Popov), Vicki Lewis (Countess Lily Malevsky-Malevitch), Penny Fuller (Dowager Empress Maria Feodorovna), Delilah Rose Pellow (Little Anastasia/Prince Alexei Romanov), Gail Bennett (Tsarina Alexandra), Tally Sessions (Tsar Nicholas II/Count Ipolitov), Allison Walsh (Olga Romanov), Kelli Youngman (Tatiana Romanov/Dunya), Maria Briggs (Maria Romanov/Marfa), Molly Rushing (Anastasia/Paulina), Ken Krugman (Gorlinsky), Ken Krugman (Count Leopold), Allison Walsh (Odette in Swan Lake), Kyle Brown (Prince Siegfried in Swan Lake), James A. Pierce III (Ensemble/Von Rothbart), Wes Hart (Russian Doorman)