Patti LuPone (Annie Oakley), Peter Gallagher (Frank Butler), Jack Dabdoub (Buffalo Bill (Col. William F. Cody)), Mary Testa (Dolly Tate), Michael McGrath (Charlie Davenport), George Lee Andrews (Pawnee Bill), Eli Wallach (Chief Sitting Bull), Cameron Bowen (Little Jake), Cassidy Ladden (Jessie Oakley), Kimberly Hannon (Nellie Oakley)