Jen Colella (Annie Oakley), Matthew Ashford (Frank Butler), Paula Leggett Chase (Dolly Tate), Joel Blum (Charlie Davenport), Patrick Boll (Buffalo Bill), Orville Mendoza (Sitting Bull), Savannah Wise (Winnie Tate), Andrew Cao (Tommy Keelor), Tim Brady (Wilson/Pawnee Bill), Michelle Coben (Jessie Oakley), Sidney Popielarchech (Nellie Oakley), Ben Nadler (Little Jake), Callan Bergmann (Messenger), Ashley Blanchet (Mrs. Sylvia Potter-Porter)