Timothy Jerome (The Proprietor), Kevin Anderson (Balladeer/Lee Harvey Oswald), Victor Garber (John Wilkes Booth), Jonathan Gold (Billy), Swoosie Kurtz (Sara Jane Moore), Christine Baranski (Lynette "Squeaky" Fromme), Paul McCrane (John Hinckley, Jr.), Nathan Lane (Samuel Byck), Michael Jeter (Giuseppe Zangara), Alma Cuervo (Emma Goldman), Anthony Heald (Leon Czolgosz), Jonathan Hadary (Charles Guiteau), Alma Cuervo, David Pursley, Joy Franz, Michael McCarty, Timothy Jerome