Princeton: Christian Earl Kate: Lauren Call Nicky: Jake T. Holt Rod: Jeremy Heaps Brian: JJ Bateman Christmas Eve: Selah McKenna Lucy the Slut/Mrs. Thistletwat: Taylor Lawrence Gary Coleman: Talia Heiss Trekkie Monster: Danny Eggers Blue Bear/Trekkie Arm: Whitney Wilde Yellow Bear: Christie Stolworthy Nicky Arm/Newcomer/Ricky: Austin Heaton