Payson Lewis (Peter Simmonds), Jonah Platt (Jason McConnell), Lindsay Pearce (Ivy Robinson), Stephanie Andersen (Sister Chantelle), Nathan Parrett (Matt Lloyd), John Griffin (Priest), Casey Hayden (Lucas Carter), Caitlin Ary (Tanya Garrett), Alissa-Nicole Koblentz (Claire Simmonds), Reesa Ishiyama (Diane Lee), Katherine Washington (Kyra), Christopher Higgins (Zack/Jake), Kelsey Hainlen (Rory), Harrison Meloeny (Alan)