Payson Lewis (Peter Simmonds), Jonah Platt (Jason McConnell), Lindsay Pearce (Ivy Robinson), Shelley Regner (u/s Nadia McConnell), Stephanie Andersen (Sister Chantelle), Nathan Parrett (Matt Lloyd), John Griffin (Priest), Casey Hayden (Lucas Carter), Caitlin Ary (Tanya Garrett), Alissa-Nicole Koblentz (Claire Simmonds), Reesa Ishiyama (Diane Lee), Katherine Washington (Kyra), Christopher Higgins (Zack/Jake), Kelsey Hainlen (Rory), Harrison Meloeny (Alan)