Jessie Mueller (Carole King), Jake Epstein (Gerry Goffin), Anika Larsen (Cynthia Weil), Jarrod Spector (Barry Mann), Jeb Brown (Don Kirshner), Liz Larsen (Genie Klein), Sara King (Marilyn Wald), Rashidra Scott (Janelle Woods/Shirelle), Ashley Blanchet (Little Eva/Shirelle), Rebecca LaChance (Betty), Josh Davis (Nick/Righteous Brother), Kevin Duda (Neil Sedaka/Righteous Brother/Lou Adler), Carly Hughes (Lucille/Shirelle)