Aaron Lazar (Billy Bigelow), Angela Gaylor (Julie Jordan), Janelle Anne Robinson (Nettie Fowler), Sarah Knapp (Carrie Pipperidge), Michael Halling (Enoch Snow), Kathryn Rossetter (Mrs. Mullin), Dimitry Christy (The Starkeeper), Alex Sanchez (Jigger Craigin), Kathy Meyer (Louise), Justin Bohon (Enoch Snow, Jr.), Sam Sinns (Fairground Boy), Tony Yazbeck (Jonathan Livermore), James Bodge (David Bascombe), Keith Andrews (Hudson Allen), Seth Muse (Abner Bentley), Sharon Richards (Arminy Chase), Laura Gaona (Ella Frazer), Kathryn Comperatore (Penny Peters), Julie Reiber (Hannah Sanborn), Stephanie Sheppard (Frances Sewell), Laura Wagner (Virginia May Sperry), Dana Steer (George Spears), Bobby Pestka (Ben Hamlin), Eric Murray (Heavenly Friend)