Christopher Sieber (Bobby/Bobbie), Judith Light (Joanne), Sharon Lawrence (Sarah), Scott Waara (Harry), Kerry O'Malley (Susan), John Scherer (Peter), Anastasia Barzee (Jenny), Kevin Chamberlin (David), Amy Pietz (April/Andy), Cady Huffman (Kathy/Theo), Deborah Gibson (Marta/PJ), Jean Louisa Kelly (Amy/Jamie), Josh Radnor (Paul), Richard Kline (Larry)