Matthew Morrison (J.M. Barrie), Laura Michelle Kelly (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Kelsey Grammer (Charles Frohman/Captain James Hook), Teal Wicks (Mary Barrie), Carolee Carmello (Mrs. du Maurier), Aidan Gemme (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Noah Hinsdale (alt Michael Llewelyn Davies), Hayden Signoretti (alt Jack Llewelyn Davies), Sawyer Nunes (George Llewelyn Davies), Melanie Moore (Peter Pan), Tyley Ross (Lord Cannan), Josh Lamon (Mr. Cromer), Paul Slade Smith (Mr. Henshaw), Chris Dwan (Elliott), Jessica Vosk (Miss Bassett), Courtney Balan (Miss Jones), Emma Pfaeffle (Wendy), Jonathan Ritter (Albert)