Billy Harrigan Tighe (J.M. Barrie), Lael Van Keuren (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), John Davidson (Charles Frohman/Captain James Hook), Kristine Reese (Mary Barrie), Karen Murphy (Mrs. du Maurier), Connor James Casey (Peter Llewelyn Davies), Tyler Patrick Hennessy (Michael Llewelyn Davies), Wyatt Cirbus (Jack Llewelyn Davies), Colin Wheeler (George Llewelyn Davies), Christina Belinsky (u/s Peter Pan), Noah Plomgren (Lord Cannan), Matt Wolpe (Mr. Cromer), Dwelvan David (Mr. Henshaw), Matthew Quinn (u/s Elliott), Victoria Huston-Elem (Miss Bassett), Caitlyn Caughell (Miss Jones), Mary Kate Harting (Wendy), Karl Skyler Urban (Albert), Connor McCrory, Melissa Hunter McCann, Will Ray