Billy Harrigan Tighe (J.M. Barrie), Lael Van Keuren (Sylvia Llewelyn Davies), Rory Donovan (t/r Charles Froman/Captain James Hook), Karen Murphy (Mrs. Du Maurier), Kristine Reese (Mary Barrie), Connor Jameson Casey (Peter), Colin Wheeler (George), Wyatt Cirbus (Jack), Tyler Patrick Hennessy (Michael), Caitlyn Caughell (Miss Jones), Matt Wolpe (Mr. Cromer), Dee Tomasetta (Peter Pan), Mary Kate Harting (Wendy), Will Ray (Acting Troupe Hook), Noah Plomgren (Lord Cannan), Karl Skyler Urban (Albert), Thomas Miller (Elliot), Dwelvan David (Mr. Henshaw), Victoria Houston-Elem (Miss Bassett), Sammy (Porthos).