Joe Machota (Ren McCormack), Nikki Scalera (Ariel Moore), Christian Borle (Willard Hewitt), Daren Kelly (Reverend Shaw Moore), Mary Gordon Murray (Vi Moore), Stephanie St James (Rusty), Katie Harvey (Wendy Jo), Michelle Kittrell (u/s Urleen), Matthew Morrison (Chuck Cranston), Marsha Waterbury (Ethel McCormack), Andrew Wright (Travis/Cowboy Bob), David Patrick Floyd (Lyle), Ted Boulton (Principal Clarke), Steve Luker (Uncle Wes), Jessica Sheridan (Eleanor), Jessica Sheridan (Irene/Betty Blast), Robert Boles (Coach Dunbar)