Bob Martin (Man in Chair), Clyde Alves (George M. Cohan [George M!]/Adi [Milk and Honey]), Reed Birney (Fodorski [All American]), Carolee Carmello (Wildy [Wildcat]), Britney Coleman (Janie [Wildcat]/Barbara [Milk and Honey]), Clifton Duncan (Gideon [Greenwillow]), Marc Kudisch (Amos [Greenwillow]/Phil [Milk and Honey]), Judy Kuhn (Elizabeth [All American]/Ruth [Milk and Honey]), Tam Mutu (Johnny [Sail Away]/David [Milk and Honey]), Bebe Neuwirth (Mimi [Sail Away]), Nancy Opel (Gramma [Greenwillow]/Clara Weiss [Milk and Honey]), Douglas Sills (Mack [Mack and Mabel]), Alexandra Socha (Mabel [Mack and Mabel]), Vanessa Williams, Joel Grey // Ensemble: Alex Aquilino, Carleigh Bettiol, Rachel Coloff, Kerry Conte, Rick Faugno, Eloise Kropp, Matt Loehr, Michael X. Martin, Michael Mendez, Justin Prescott, Wayne Pretlow, Lindsay Roberts, Steve Routman, Sarah Jane Shanks, Jaquez Sims, Diana Vaden, Jessica Wockenfuss