Darren Criss (J. Pierrepont Finch), Beau Bridges (J.B. Biggley), Rose Hemingway (Rosemary Pilkington), Tammy Blanchard (Hedy La Rue), Christopher Hanke (Bud Frump), Rob Bartlett (Mr. Twimble), Mary Faber (Smitty), Ellen Harvey (Miss Jones), Michael Park (Bert Bratt)