Jennifer Mudge (Witch), Ben Steinfeld (Baker), Jessie Austrian (Baker's Wife), Claire Karpen (Cinderella), Emily Young (Little Red Riding Hood), Patrick Mulryan (Jack), Noah Brody (Wolf/Cinderella's Prince), Andy Grotelueschen (Rapunzel's Prince), Paul L Coffey (Mysterious Man), Liz Hayes (Jack's Mother), Liz Hayes (Cinderella's Stepmother), Andy Grotelueschen (Florinda), Noah Brody (Lucinda), Patrick Mulryan (Steward), Emily Young (Rapunzel), Andy Grotelueschen (Milky White), Claire Karpen (Granny)