Donna Murphy (Witch), Denis O'Hare (Baker), Amy Adams (Baker's Wife), Jessie Mueller (Cinderella), Sarah Stiles (Little Red Riding Hood), Gideon Glick (Jack), Ivan Hernandez (Wolf/Cinderella's Prince), Paris Remillard (u/s Rapunzel's Prince), Noah Radcliffe (u/s Narrator), Chip Zien (Mysterious Man), Kristine Zbornik (Jack's Mother), Ellen Harvey (Cinderella's Stepmother), Bethany Moore (Florinda), Chip Zien (Cinderella's Father)