Donna Murphy (Witch), Denis O'Hare (Baker), Amy Adams (Baker's Wife), Jessie Mueller (Cinderella), Sarah Stiles (Little Red Riding Hood), Gideon Glick (Jack), Ivan Hernandez (Wolf/Cinderella's Prince), Cooper Grodin (Rapunzel's Prince), Jack Broderick (Narrator), Chip Zien (Mysterious Man), Kristine Zbornik (Jack's Mother), Ellen Harvey (Cinderella's Stepmother), Bethany Moore (Florinda), Jennifer Rias (Lucinda), Chip Zien (Cinderella's Father), Tess Soltau (Rapunzel)