Christian Borle (Noble Eggleston/Pinchley/Val du Val/Fred Poitrine/Otto/Prince/Noble, Jr.), Rachel York (Belle), Judy Kaye (Older Belle), Harriet Harris (Mrs. Eggleston), Robert Creighton (Pinchley, Jr./Defense Lawyer/Preacher/German Soldier/General/Assistant Director/Yulnick), Tony Yazbeck (George Musgrove) David Garrison (Patrick Dennis), Lewis J. Stadlen (Bennie Buchsbaum), Lee Wilkof (Bernie Buchsbaum)