Bryce Pinkham (Don Quixote), Jason Danieley (Don Quixote), Marc Kudisch (Don Quixote), Santino Fontana (Don Quixote), Alexandra Silber (Aldonza), Bryonha Marie Parham (Aldonza), Julia Murney (Aldonza), Sherry D Boone (Aldonza), Brandon Uranowitz (Sancho), DC Anderson (Sancho), Jason SweetTooth Williams (Sancho), Robert Creighton (Sancho), John Cariano (Anselmo), Jessica Fontana (Antonia), Andrew Samonsky (Padre), Hunter Ryan Herdlicka (Padre), Stanley Bahorek (Padre), Mary Testa (Housekeeper), George Abud (Barber), Tally Sessions (Innkeeper)