Jenn Colella (Peter Pan), Charles Shaugnessy (Captain Hook), Sophie Aknin (Tootles), Mei Lu Barnum (2nd Twin), Desiree Davar (Liza/Tiger Lily), Daniel Frotz (Michael Darling), Trisha Holmes (Jane), Nathan Levy (Curly), Tuan Malinowski (1st Twin), Lori Eve Marinacci (Wendy Darling), Tommy Martinez (Slightly), Patrick Richwood (Mr. Smee), Erika Strasburg (Mrs. Darling/Mermaid), Mario Williams (John Darling)