Michael Mahony (Peter Pan), Rhiannon Chesterman (Wendy Darling), Rea Campbell-Hill (Michael Darling/Emma the Mermaid), Christopher Finn (John Darling/Jay the Mermaid), Allison Harding (Nanny Cookson/Captain Jess Hook), Alan Richardson (George Darling/Bah-Ree, Queen of the Mermaids/Great Big Little Panther), Colette Lennon-Dougal (Mary Darling/Tiger Lily), Christina Nelson (Miss Liza/Miss Smee), Connor Rogers