Christine Baranski (Marie), Alec Baldwin (Peter), Ellen Barkin (Simone), Matthew Broderick (Lucifer), Melissa Errico (Musical Interludes performer), Halley Feiffer (Amy), Boyd Gaines (Sam), Cady Huffman (Introducer), Patricia Kalember (Mary), Kevin Kline (Jim), Tony Kushner (Himself), Angela Lansbury (Hannah), Kathleen McNenny (Amy's Mom), Bette Midler (Nora), Chris O'Donnell (Max), Tony Roberts (Jerry), Raúl Esparza (Performer - "A Gift from Stephen Sondheim")