Gavin Creel (Melchior Gabor), Lea Michele (Wendla Bergmann), Eric Millegan (Moritz Stiefel), Bridget Berger (Ilse Neumann), Nikki M James (Martha Bessell), Chris Garneau (Hanschen Rilow), Alex Brummel (Otto Lämmermeier), Frank Wood (The Adult Men), Michael McElroy (The Masked Man), John Sullivan, Michael Benjamin Washington