Alexander Gemignani (u/s Sweeney Todd), Judy Kaye (Mrs. Lovett), Benjamin Magnuson (Anthony Hope), Lauren Molina (Johanna), Keith Buterbaugh (Judge Turpin), Edmund Bagnell (Tobias Ragg), Benjamin Eakeley (Beadle Bamford), Diana DiMarzio (Beggar Woman), Katrina Yaukey (Adolfo Pirelli)