Justin Vivian Bond (Anna Madrigal), Betsy Wolfe (Mary Ann Singleton), Wesley Taylor (Michael "Mouse" Tolliver), Jose Llana (Brian Hawkins), Kathleen Elizabeth Monteleone (DeDe Halcyon-Day), Mary Birdsong (Mona Ramsey), Josh Breckenridge (Jon Fielding), Jeffrey Carlson (Beauchamp Day), Diane J Findlay (Mother Mucca), Stephen Schnetzer (Edgar Halcyon), Rachel Dratch (Anita Bryant)