Andrew Rannells (Elder Price), Josh Gad (Elder Cunningham), Nikki M. James (Nabulungi), Rory O'Malley (Elder McKinley, Moroni), Michael Potts (Mafala Hatimbi), Lewis Cleale (Price's Dad, Mission President, Jesus), Brian Tyree Henry (General), Scott Barnhardt (Elder Thomas), Justin Bohon (Elder Zelder), Darlesia Cearcy, Kevin Duda (Cunningham's Dad, Elder Neeley, Hitler), Valisia LeKae (swing), Clark Johnsen (Elder Michaels), John Eric Parker (Guard), Benjamin Schrader (Elder Schrader, Jeffrey Dahmer, Yoda), Michael James Scott (Doctor), Brian Sears (Elder Church), Jason Michael Snow (Elder Davis), Lawrence Stallings, Rema Webb (Mrs. Brown), Maia Nkenge Wilson (Ghengis Khan), Tommar Wilson (Guard)