Andrew Rannells (Elder Price), Josh Gad (Elder Cunningham), Nikki M. James (Nabulungi), Rory O'Malley (Elder McKinley), Michael Potts (Mafala Hatimbi), Brian Tyree Henry (General), Lewis Cleale (Joseph Smith/Price's Dad/Mission President), Kevin Duda (Cunningham's Dad/Ensemble), Jason Michael Snow (Mormon/Ensemble), Rema Webb (Mrs. Brown/Ensemble), Michael James Scott (Doctor/Ensemble)