Jonathan Crombie (Man in Chair), Jen Taylor Farrell (u/s Janet van de Graaf), Alicia Irving (The Drowsy Chaperone), Mark Ledbetter (Robert Martin), Noble Shropshire (Underling), Richard Vida (George), Peter Riopelle (Gangster #1), Paul Riopelle (Gangster #2), Cliff Bemis (Mr. Feldzieg), Linda Griffin (Kitty), Georgia Engel (Mrs. Tottendale), Dale Hensley (Aldolpho), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Trix)