Laura Benanti (Rosabella), Shuler Hensley (Tony), Jessica Molaskey (Marie), Brian Cali (Ciccio), Kevin Vortmann (Postman/Doctor/Cashier), Heidi Blickenstaff (Cleo), Zachary James (Pasquale), Bradley Dean (Giuseppe), Cheyenne Jackson (Joe), Jay Armstrong Johnson (Herman), Christopher Rice (Max/The Priest), Ward Billeisen (Clem), Ryan Bauer-Walsh (Jake)