Andrew Samonsky (Harold Hill), Jeffry Denman (Harold Hill), John Ellison Conlee (Harold Hill), Santino Fontana (Harold Hill), Alexandra Silber (Marian Paroo), Betsy Wolfe (Marian Paroo), Jessica Hershberg (Marian Paroo), Laura Osnes (Marian Paroo), Ann Harada (Mrs. Paroo), David Greenspan (Marcellus Washburn), Andrew Keenan-Bolger (Winthrop Paroo), Susan Blair Ross (Eulalie Shinn), Robert Lenzi (Oliver Hix), Richard Costa (Olin Britt), Stanley Bahorek (Jacey Squires), Bob Stillman (Ewart Dunlop)