Ted Keegan (u/s The Phantom of the Opera), Kaley Ann Voorhees (alt Christine Daaé), Jay Armstrong Johnson (Raoul), Raquel Suarez Groen (Carlotta Giudicelli), Carrington Vilmont (u/s Monsieur Firmin), Scott Mikita (u/s Monsieur André), Maree Johnson (Madame Giry), Chris Georgetti (u/s Ubaldo Piangi), Jessica Bishop (Meg Giry)