Phillipa Soo (Catalina), John Ellison Conlee (Mayor Evans), Layla Khoshnoudi (Alice), Randy Danson (Prudence), Andy Grotelueschen (Chappy), Andrew Garman (Bill Yardley), Gibson Frazier (Doc Alonzo), Bill Buell (Sam), Chinaza Uche (Clement), Matthew Dean Marsh (Pirate)