Jason Hite (Jason McConnell), Taylor Trensch (Peter Simonds), Sara Kapner (u/s Ivy Robinson), Barrett Wilbert Weed (Nadia McConnell), Gerard Canonico (Matt Lloyd), Missi Pyle (Sister Joan), Anthony Festa (u/s Father Mike), Alice Lee (Diane Lee), Alex Wyse (Alan), Justin Gregory Lopez (Beto), Ariana Groover (Vanessa) (also known as Ari Groover), Megan Lewis (u/s Madison)